Court Documents

 

Date: 26 January, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Document Type: Pleading

Our Notice of Civil Claim is the formal process by which a suit is commenced. It explains who the parties to the litigation are, what the cause of action is (underlying legal theory that is the basis for the suit), and what we’d like a judge to do about it.

View


Date: 4 March, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application

A Request for Assignment of Judge is required for any class proceeding. All class proceedings are judicially managed in British Columbia. This means the same judge presides over all hearings, as opposed to a random one for each application. This is required under Practice Direction No 5. This has been the norm since 2010.

View


Date: 31 March, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Pleading

The Defendants’ Response to Civil Claim contains their position and why the government believes it has done nothing wrong.

View


Date: 21 June, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Case Plan Proposal

Our case plan proposal outlining proposed steps and timelines for this civil proceeding. This document will be tabled before our judge at our judicial management conference currently scheduled for 10 August, 2021.

View


Date: 5 July, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Case Plan Proposal

Dr. Bonnie Henry and the Crowns’ case plan proposal outlining proposed steps and timelines for this civil proceeding. This document will be tabled before our judge at our judicial management conference currently scheduled for 10 August, 2021.

View


Date: 13 August, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Requisition

CSASPP’s requisition confirming a Judicial Management Conference to be held by consent of the parties on 1 October, 2021, at 9 AM for one hour by telephone.

View


Date: 17 August, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Demand for Particulars

Dr. Bonnie Henry and the Crown have requested additional details in relation to CSASPP’s claim. This is done pursuant to Rule 3-7.

View


Date: 30 August, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Response to Demand for Particulars

CSASPP’s response to Dr. Bonnie Henry and the Crown’s request for additional details in relation to CSASPP’s claim.

View


Date: 30 August, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

CSASPP provides notice to Dr. Bonnie Henry and the Crown that it intends to seek injunctive relief against the new provincial health order announced 23 August, 2021. The order will require individuals to provide proof of injections to access a broad range of venues. It is difficult to challenge when the order has not been made public, so a copy is requested from the defendants.

View


Date: 3 September, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

The defendants’ response to our letter of 30 August, 2021. We are advised that the injection passport order is not publicly available and that no timeline for its availability was provided either.

View


Date: 13 September, 2021

Author: Transcriber

File No: S-219760 (Petition opposing injection passport)

Type: Transcript and reasons for judgment

Transcript of the exchange between Registrar Nielsen, Crown counsel, and CSASPP counsel. This was from our 13 September, 2021, hearing in general chambers seeking short leave to have an application heard seeking a stay of the injection passport public health order.

View

Oral reasons for judgment of Registrar Nielsen of the aforementioned.

View


Date: 15 September, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Amended Pleading

CSASPP Amended Notice of Civil Claim filed and served on the defendants 15 September, 2021. Text that has been underlined has been added. Text that has been struck through has been removed.

View


Date: 28 September, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Agenda for Judicial Management Conference

This document was drafted by Crown counsel in consultation with CSASPP. It outlines the agenda to be discussed with Justice Crerar at our Judicial Management Conference of 1 October, 2021.

View


Date: 1 October, 2021

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Orders (Judicial Management Conference)

Orders made by Justice Crerar on 1 October, 2021, following our Judicial Management Conference. These orders were entered 29 November, 2021.

View


Date: 15 October, 2021

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Orders (Judicial Management Conference)

This document contains the orders made at our Judicial Management Conference hearing of 10 August, 2021, before Justice Crerar. It was entered by the registry on 15 October, 2021.

View


Date: 18 October, 2021

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application

Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crowns' application to seek additional details from CSASPP on the specifics of what the defendants are being sued for. Note that due to a clerical error, this copy provided by the defendants’ does not contain a registry filing stamp.

View


Date: 25 October, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Affidavit

This is an affidavit from CSASPP's Executive Director in response to the defendants' application seeking further particulars (details) on what they are being sued for.

View


Date: 25 October, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application Response

CSASPP's application response to Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crowns' application. The latter seeks additional details from CSASPP on the specifics of what the defendants are being sued for.

View


Date: 28 October, 2021

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Orders (Chamber Application)

Orders made by Justice Crerar on 28 October, 2021, following Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crowns' application for further and better particulars.

View


Date: 28 October, 2021

Author: Transcriber

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Transcript

Transcript of the exchange between Crown counsel, CSASPP counsel, and Justice Crerar from 28 October, 2021, in respect to the application of Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crown seeking further and better particulars to CSASPP's amended pleadings of 15 September, 2021.

View


Date: 28 October, 2021

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Reasons for Judgment

Oral reasons for judgment from Justice Crerar in chambers of 28 October, 2021, in respect to the application of Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crown seeking further and better particulars to CSASPP's amended pleadings of 15 September, 2021.

View


Date: 4 November, 2021

Author: Petitioner (CSASPP)

File No: S-219760 (Petition opposing injection passport)

Type: Petition

Petition seeking judicial review of the defendants’ injection passport public health orders.

View


Date: 4 November, 2021

Author: Petitioner (CSASPP)

File No: S-219760 (Petition opposing injection passport)

Type: Affidavit

Executive Director’s affidavit in support of our petition seeking judicial review of the respondents’ injection passport public health orders.

View


Date: 8 November, 2021

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Response to Demand for Particulars

CSASPP's Response to Demand for Particulars of Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crown, pursuant to the order of Justice Crerar in chambers of 28 October, 2021. The defendants sought further and better particulars to CSASPP's amended pleadings of 15 September, 2021.

View


Date: 26 November, 2021

Author: Petitioner (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Petition

CSASPP’s petition on behalf of all health care workers affected by an injection mandate.

View


Date: 26 November, 2021

Author: Petitioner (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Affidavit

Affidavit by CSASPP's Executive Director in support of CSASPP's petition opposing an injection mandate to all affected health care workers.

View


Date: 26 November, 2021

Author: Petitioner (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Affidavit

Affidavit by Laurie Bridge, petitioner counsel’s paralegalist, in support of CSASPP's petition opposing an injection mandate to all affected health care workers.

View


Date: 10 January, 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application

The Plaintiff’s application seeking class certification.

View


Date: 14 January, 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

A letter from the plaintiff to the Court regarding facilitating public access to hearings.

View


Date: 21 January, 2022

Author: Respondent (Dr. Bonnie Henry)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Response to Petition

Dr. Henry's response to CSASPP's petition of 26 November, 2021. The latter was brought on behalf of all health care workers affected by an injection mandate.

View


Date: 21 January, 2022

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Orders (Judicial Management Conference)

Various procedural orders made by the Hon. Justice Crerar on 21 January, 2022, and entered by the Registry 14 March, 2022. These orders grant CSASPP's request to amend its certification application by 15 February, 2022, the defendants a time extension for responding materials, and a new judicial management conference scheduled for 21 April, 2022.

View


Date: 28 February, 2022

Author: Petitioner (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Petition

CSASPP’s amended petition on behalf of all health care workers affected by an injection mandate. The original was filed and served on the respondent 26 November, 2021. This amended version was filed 28 February, 2022.

View


Date: 12 April, 2022

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Affidavit

Affidavit No 1 of Dr. Brian Emerson, Deputy Provincial Health Officer.

View


Date: 3 May, 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application

CSASPP’s application to amend pleadings to insert additional representative plaintiffs and other amendments.

View


Date: 4 May, 2022

Author: Court

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Reasons for judgment

Justice Coval in his reasons for judgment rules that CSASPP has public interest standing.

View


Date: 3 June, 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application

CSASPP's application seeking certification of its proposed class proceeding. Returnable 12-16 December, 2022, before Justice Crerar. Some redactions have been applied.

View


Date: 26 July, 2022

Author: Plaintiff and Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Agenda for Judicial Management Conference

This document was drafted by both CSASPP and Crown counsel. It outlines the agenda to be discussed with Justice Crerar at our Judicial Management Conference of 28 July, 2022.

View


Date: 2 August, 2022

Author: Respondent (Dr. Henry)

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Notice of Abandonment

Justice Coval awarded CSASPP public interest standing on 4 May, 2022. Dr. Henry provided notice she wished to appeal his ruling. On 2 August, 2022, she abandoned her pursuit of an appeal.

View


Date: 12 September, 2022

Author: Court

File No: S-219760 (Petition opposing injection passport)

Type: Reasons for judgment

Chief Justice Hinkson’s ruling on CSASPP’s petition opposing the injection passport.

View


Date: 7 October, 2022

Author: Appellant (CSASPP)

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Notice of Appeal

Chief Justice Hinkson issued his ruling on CSASPP’s petition opposing the injection passport on 12 September, 2022. It was dismissed on technical grounds. This document formally initiates the appeal process in the British Columbia Court of Appeal.

View


Date: 12 October, 2022

Author: Respondent (Dr. Henry)

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Notice of Appearance

Dr. Henry's formal confirmation that her counsel will participate in CSASPP's appeal Chief Justice Hinkson's ruling dismissing its injection passport petition on technical grounds.

View


Date: 14 October, 2022

Author: Petitioners (counsel for third party petitioners, not us)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Requisition - General

Peter Gall, a lawyer for a petition that is to be heard concurrently with CSASPP's health care workers' injection passport petition, requested a judicial management conference for the morning of 19 October, 2022, before Justice Coval, to discuss several procedural issues relating to admissible evidence.

View


Date: 20 October, 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Affidavit

CSASPP's Executive Director's affidavit in support of its open court application. Note that due to a minor clerical error, this affidavit should have been assigned ordinal 4 and not 3.

View


Date: 26 October, 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Notice of Application

CSASPP's application for allowing offline video recording and archival of the certification hearing. It does this by refining the constitutionally protected definition of an open court in a contemporary context. This application was returnable, at the time of filing, 7 November, 2022, before Justice Crerar.

View


Date: 27 October, 2022

Author: Petitioners (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Letter

Cover letter for CSASPP's further amended petition for health care workers'. This letter was served on Dr. Henry with the accompanying revised petition of the same date.

View


Date: 27 October, 2022

Author: Petitioners (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Petition

CSASPP’s third revision of its health care workers’ petition. It makes several amendments necessary to address Dr. Henry’s 12 September, 2022, public health order.

View


Date: 28 October, 2022

Author: Petitioners (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Letter

CSASPP’s letter to Dr. Henry requesting she provide the scientific basis for her orders.

View


Date: 28 October, 2022

Author: Petitioners (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Letter

CSASPP requests Dr. Henry re-assess the underlying circumstance which gave rise to her 12 September, 2022, public health order which affected health care workers in hospitals. This is for CSASPP's health care workers' petition. The request is made under s. 45 of the Public Health Act, SBC 2008, c. 28.

View


Date: 1 November 2022

Author: Respondent (paralegalist for Dr. Henry)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Affidavit

This document forms part of the materials provided by Dr. Henry's counsel in opposition to CSASPP's application to webcast the certification hearing in our class proceeding. It is an affidavit provided by a para legalist in the Legal Services Branch of the BC AG. Some good faith redactions have been performed on our part to protect their identity.

View


Date: 2 November 2022

Author: Respondent (Attorney General of British Columbia)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application Response

This document forms part of the materials provided by Dr. Henry's counsel in opposition to CSASPP's application to webcast the certification hearing in our class proceeding. It sets out the basis for why the Attorney General opposed our application.

View


Date: 2 November 2022

Author: Respondent (Dr. Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Application Response

This document forms part of the materials provided by Dr. Henry's counsel in opposition to CSASPP's application to webcast the certification hearing in our class proceeding. It sets out the basis for why Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crown opposed our application.

View


Date: 7 November, 2022

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Reasons for judgment

Justice Crerar’s reasons for judgment in respect to our application to webcast our certification hearing.

View


Date: 15 November, 2022

Author: Respondent

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Requisition - General

Dr. Henry’s requisition to set down a case planning conference for 16 November, 2022, before Justice Coval.

View


Date: 23 November, 2022

Author: Respondent

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Application (unfiled)

Dr. Henry’s application to strike various affidavits.

View


Date: 29 November 2022

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Affidavit

Affidavit of Zubin Parihar in support of CSASPP’s application seeking class certification.

View


Date: 30 November, 2022

Author: Petitioner

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Application Response

CSASPP’s response to Dr. Henry’s application to strike various affidavits.

View


Date: 13 January, 2023

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Requisition

Dr. Henry and the Provincial Crown's requisition to set down a continuation of the class proceeding's certification hearing set to resume 24 April, 2023, for five days. This follows the previous five days that began on 12 December, 2022. Both sets of dates were mutually agreed upon by the parties.

View


Date: 13 January, 2023

Author: Court of Appeal Registrar

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Letter

BC Court of Appeal Registrar rejects Dr. Henry's request for a preliminary mootness application in CSASPP's appeal of Chief Justice Hinkson's dismissal of the petition challenging the injection passport.

View


Date: 16 January, 2023

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Affidavit

Affidavit No 3 of Dr. Brian Emerson, Deputy Provincial Health Officer, in response to CSASPP's request for particulars of 21 December, 2022. Dr. Emerson claims that the BCCDC is not a party to this proceeding because it is a program of the Provincial Health Services Authority. The defendants intend to rely upon this affidavit at the certification continuation scheduled to resume 24 April, 2023.

View


Date: 16 January, 2023

Author: Appellant (CSASPP)

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Factum

CSASPP's factum in its appeal of Chief Justice Hinkson's ruling of 12 September, 2022, dismissing the plaintiffs' constitutional challenge. The latter sought judicial review of the injection passport public health orders of Dr. Bonnie Henry. The original reasons for judgement are indexed as Canadian Society for the Advancement of Science in Public Policy v. British Columbia, 2022 BCSC 1606.

View


Date: 28 February, 2023

Author: Court

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Reasons for judgment

Justice Coval's reasons for judgment of 28 February, 2023, dismissing the petitioners' applications to augment the evidentiary record that was before Dr. Henry at the time she issued her orders mandating injections for health care workers.

View


Date: 7 March, 2023

Author: Petitioners (CSASPP et al.)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Letter

CSASPP and other petitioners request a corrigendum of Justice Coval's ruling of 28 February, 2023. The ruling dismissed an application seeking to augment the record in our health care workers' petition.

View


Date: 9 March, 2023

Author: Court

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Letter

Justice Coval acknowledges petitioners' letter of 7 March, 2023, and accepts need for corrections of his ruling of 28 February, 2023. The ruling dismissed an application seeking to augment the record in our health care workers' petition.

View


Date: 30 March, 2023

Author: Court

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Letter

Justice Coval particularizes the corrections he made to his previous ruling of 28 February, 2023, at which time he dismissed Peter Gall's application to augment the evidentiary record.

View


Date: 30 March 2023

Author: Court

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Corrected reasons for judgment

Justice Coval's corrected reasons for judgment of 28 February, 2023, dismissing the petitioners' applications to augment the evidentiary record that was before Dr. Henry at the time she issued her orders mandating injections for health care workers.

View


Date: 24 May, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Proposed further amended notice of civil claim

Proposed further amended notice of civil claim in our class proceeding. This is a clean copy.

View


Date: 5 June, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Highlighted proposed further amended notice of civil claim

Proposed further amended notice of civil claim in our class proceeding. This is a marked up copy with proposed changes colour coded.

View


Date: 5 June, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

Letter to Justice Crerar pursuant to his direction of 28 April, 2023, to address any issues still outstanding following the conclusion of our certification hearing.

View


Date: 6 June, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-2110229 (Petition for health care workers)

Type: Discontinuance

Discontinuance of our health care workers' petition.

View


Date: 13 June, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Requisition

Requisition to set a Judicial Management Conference in our class proceeding before Justice Crerar for 28 August, 2023, at 0900 for one hour. The hearing was requested by Dr. Henry as discussed in our letter to Justice Crerar of 5 June, 2023.

View


Date: 29 June, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

CSASPP requests details on reasons for Dr. Henry having requested a Judicial Management Conference 28 August, 2023.

View


Date: 15 August, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

CSASPP provides a mutually proposed schedule for further submissions in respect to our certification application and its accompanying proposed amended pleading.

View


Date: 16 August, 2023

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

Justice Crerar approves of the schedule proposed in our letter to the Court of 15 August, 2023.

View


Date: 29 August, 2023

Author: Respondent (Dr. Henry)

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Factum

Dr. Henry's argument for her application to dismiss CSASPP's injection passport appeal on grounds of mootness. The appeal was brought by CSASPP in respect of Chief Justice Hinkson's ruling striking its petition seeking judicial review of various injection passport related PHOs of Dr. Henry.

View


Date: 30 August, 2023

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

Crown counsel's cover letter to their supplemental submissions in our class proceeding in respect to our certification application and our recently proposed amended pleading.

View


Date: 30 August, 2023

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Written submissions

Crown counsel's supplemental submissions in our class proceeding in respect to our certification application and our recently proposed amended pleading.

View


Date: 15 September, 2023

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter with written submissions

CSASPP's supplemental submissions in respect to Dr. Henry's of 30 August, 2023. These submissions are in support of our application for leave to amend our pleading as part of our certification application.

View


Date: 21 September, 2023

Author: Defendants (Dr. Bonnie Henry & Provincial Crown)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter with written submissions

Dr. Henry's supplemental reply submissions in respect to CSASPP's of 15 September, 2023. These submissions oppose CSASPP's application for leave to amend its pleading as part of its application for certification.

View


Date: 6 October, 2023

Author: Court

File No: CA48599 (Appealing Chief Justice’ ruling in S-219760)

Type: Reasons for Judgment

Oral reasons for judgment from Justices Groberman, Abrioux, and Skolrood issued 6 October, 2023, and published 12 October, 2023. The judgment is in respect of the respondent’s application to declare the appellants’ appeals as moot. The Court determined that the appeals are moot, but opted to exercise its discretion nevertheless to hear several of them.

View


Date: 11 December, 2023

Author: Court

File No: CV-22-00683322-0000 (Galati’s defamation claim)

Type: Reasons for Judgment

Justice Chalmers’ reasons for judgment in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissing Rocco Galati’s claim that was brought in defamation against CSASPP. More information available here.

View


Date: 3 February, 2024

Author: Court

File No: CV-22-00683322-0000 (Galati’s defamation claim)

Type: Reasons for Judgment

Justice Chalmers’ reasons for judgment in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice fixing costs against Rocco Galati at $132,268.17. More information available here.

View


Date: 7 February, 2024

Author: Defendants (CSASPP)

File No: CV-22-00683322-0000 (Galati’s defamation claim)

Type: Order

Entered order with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice registry dismissing Galati’s claim and awarding costs on a full indemnity basis to CSASPP in the amount of $132,268.17. More information available here.

View


Date: 2 April, 2024

Author: Court

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Memorandum to Counsel / Parties

Justice Crerar advises CSASPP and Dr. Henry that he anticipates his ruling on our class action's certification application to be released at some point in April or May 2024.

View


Date: 12 April, 2024

Author: Plaintiff (CSASPP)

File No: S-210831 (Class proceeding for everyone)

Type: Letter

CSASPP's letter to Justice Crerar in response to his own of 2 April, 2024. At that time Justice Crerar had requested additional authorities decided since our submissions ended on 29 September, 2023, that bear upon the issues raised in our certification application. We have provided a list of ten authorities with a summary of each.

View